Thursday, May 24, 2007

Race to Win... are we losing the track?

People want to win! Lets face it... all of us have evolved from apes. We still have some killer instinct left intact within us which is why we still get to see and hear gory tales of people killing each other for issues ranging from money to marriage!
Yesterday, the Std 12 CBSE results were announced and 2 of my cousins had their results declared! Both of them were smart kids, hard workers and aspired to be amongst the creme' de la creme'.
Unfortunately their scores do not find a place in the upper score rung and immediately there was a wave of soberness that spread amongst all of us at home. I found that even I was a little upset with their scores because all along we had very high expectations on both of them.
In the calm of the night when I introspected, I was struggling to understand why most people including me; associate success and intelligence with just the scores? I knew for sure that both these young lads were street smart, they were active learners and sincere in whatever they have been doing so far!
So, in the place of appreciating them for what they have gone through, everyone was sad and depressed about some unknown reason!
Why do we have this kind of perception? Whom do we blame for this? Do we blame ourselves for being so narrow in our approach? Or is it because our education system is structured to reward only those who score well in tests? What about those who do not score? Can we brand them to be stupid and dull? What about all those people who have been successful in spite of being poor scorers?
In this race towards god knows where, are we losing the track???
I am left wondering...are you?

J.

2 comments:

Vinaya Gangalam(Vinay) said...

Couple of things here -

1 - Regarding your cousins, reaching people expectations are always tough. First of all, I don't understand why everyone is so much worried about them. I believe that is one of the important reasons(people intervention) that effect the performance of anyone. I am sure that these kids are more depressed than anyone, but this time for the wrong reasons. Instead of thinking in the lines of what went wrong in their preparation strategy, they are more concerned about people taking about them. Its none-of-business for anyone as a matter of fact to express their deep concerns and too much taking about others. Things go wrong at times, people needed to be supported.
2 - Intelligence & scores are e different things. Competition is requires strategy, and little bit of intelligence. Regarding these kids, taking about intelligence and scores is little too much. May be they went wrong in few things, its is no way related to their intelligence. I was preparing for the IIT, I spent 2 solid years of time not even watching TV, doing nothing other than studying. End result, I didnt clear the exam. I spent 2 years, people had deep concerns and expressed their sorrow for not getting through the exam(it was irritating). I'll blame it on me for the result. My preparation was not to the standards that are required to clear IIT. I would say something would have happened in their case as well. But, I still believe(strongly) that its the kids who have to figure it out. I am sure they know what went wrong, and others like us should give them time and support(if requested) to help them.

Aditya Venkataraman said...

Even though the desperate need of the hour is a serious review of our education system, one has to accept the fact that when 4 lakh students are competing for 4000 seats, the only method of evaluation humanly possible is going by test marks.